Filmology
MOVIES: OBJECTIVE OR SUBJECTIVE?
Everyone has different opinions on movies. These opinions, while they generally are affected by objective factors of the movie, are typically a generally subjective thing. I believe we can gain much by examining this intertwining relationship between subjectivity and objectivity and using it to shape our thoughts. Doing this requires a more conscious self-analysis than is typically done when viewing a film, but it can enhance our understanding of film and increase the benefits we gain from it.
The Sides
PERSONAL FEELINGS
I have heard similar things to this message on the right often. People claim that movies are art and therefore opinions on them are entirely subjective and have no grounding in any form of science. I agree that movies are art and subjectivity plays a major factor in the resulting opinions people have of them, but this is not the whole story.
DEFINITIVE TALENT, SKILL, OR PROFICIENCY
Regardless of what someone thinks of a movie, there are a lot of factors that went into the production. The cinematographer, who has spent countless hours honing his craft, provides beautiful shots with a trained eye. The actors study extensively to be able to accurately portray their characters. Skilled writers jot down complex plots full of literary devices.
A MERGING OF BOTH
Yes, we all have our own opinions, but these are heavily influenced on objective factors to varying degrees. Of course, a movie being well crafted does not necessarily mean we have to like the movie. Unfortunately, the two sides become very muddled as many do not take care to separate the two from their thoughts or statements. In fact, most are not even consciously aware of the two different sides when they think about their opinion.
​
There are many reasons for understanding the interaction of subjectivity and objectivity in film. It allows us to tell what is actually contributing to our opinions so that we can discern why we like or dislike a movie. This also allows us to have a more informed opinion, better provide discussion and recommendations to others, and allows us to promote the continuation of positive aspects of films and affect their future.
​
See the other pages of this website at the top for a more detailed breakdown of these factors and how we should go about thinking through movies to gain a better understanding.
“The very concept of objective truth is fading out of the world. Lies will pass into history.”
GEORGE ORWELL
FILMOLOGY